I've been asked more than once if columnist David Brooks is an intellectual. I think he is--he's just not a good one. Put it this way. Some gynecologists are excellent doctors, but we knew one whose nickname was "Ironfinger."
In his latest column Brooks sets out to tell us what makes us equal. We aren't equally smart or tall or rich, but "all humans have souls." These items "make us all radically equal." And if citizens "lose the concept of soul, they have lost everything."
This argument looks somewhat logical if you believe souls exist, in which case I have a tooth fairy I'd like to sell you. The claim that our souls make us equal is sometimes taught in introductions to 18th century American thought. Brooks' discussion of souls today resembles Trump's discussion of Frederick Douglas.
But let's agree that souls do exist. Why believe that all souls are equal? What evidence is there to back the assertion that Billie Holiday and Rudy Giuliani are equally soulful?
Saturday, October 12, 2019
Tuesday, October 8, 2019
The Mandate of Heaven
Soon we (fanatical centrists like Joe Biden) will be facing a key question. Is President Trump guilty of the crimes he confessed to on national television? The Republicans say no. Nancy Pelosi wants to see more evidence.
Rick Perry might be to blame for the confessions. Or the President, in his great and unmatched wisdom, might have been joking with the press. I have never seen him smile, but maybe he enjoys a night out and a good laugh with Rand Paul.
I noticed that Pat Robertson is not laughing. When informed that the President was abandoning our allies, the Kurds, to be slaughtered by the Turkish army, Robertson said that Trump was in danger of "losing the mandate of Heaven."
Meanwhile, Jerry Falwell is still dead.
Rick Perry might be to blame for the confessions. Or the President, in his great and unmatched wisdom, might have been joking with the press. I have never seen him smile, but maybe he enjoys a night out and a good laugh with Rand Paul.
I noticed that Pat Robertson is not laughing. When informed that the President was abandoning our allies, the Kurds, to be slaughtered by the Turkish army, Robertson said that Trump was in danger of "losing the mandate of Heaven."
Meanwhile, Jerry Falwell is still dead.
Monday, October 7, 2019
Thaddeus
Back in the 1950s, when I was being badly educated, I learned that Thaddeus Stevens, a prominent congress member in the Civil War era, was a horrible man. I was taught that Stevens was a "Radical Republican," who pushed hard to punish the South for its sins, making knitting the divided nation together in 1866 difficult. Thaddeus Stevens wouldn't let the wounds heal.
That made good sense if you didn't know that Stevens had devoted his life--and risked it--to fighting slavers. He was a working-class guy whose mother somehow managed to put him through Dartmouth, which led him to a leadership position. He was known for what we now call empathy and generosity. Once when he learned that a widow was about to lose her home, he bought it and gave it to her. He was also known for brilliant maneuvers and sarcastic wit on the floor of congress.
The negative view in California history texts of the Radical Republicans went along with admiration for the chivalrous Robert E. Lee, who once had an enslaved black woman whipped for insolence.
What had actually made Thaddeus Stevens a villain in American history texts--I discovered many years later-- was his absolute insistence that black men be given citizenship and the right to vote, to sit on juries and to own property after the Civil War. Stevens--who lived with a woman of mixed race and left her a pension when he died-- had no doubt that all men are created equal. At the time (and for the next hundred years), many white men considered that view radical, absurd, even evil.
A few years ago there was a popular movie about a short section of Lincoln's life, and in it, Thaddeus Stevens, played by Tommy Lee Jones, was accurately portrayed as a tough and witty progressive who knew when to compromise. The times they are a'changing.
That made good sense if you didn't know that Stevens had devoted his life--and risked it--to fighting slavers. He was a working-class guy whose mother somehow managed to put him through Dartmouth, which led him to a leadership position. He was known for what we now call empathy and generosity. Once when he learned that a widow was about to lose her home, he bought it and gave it to her. He was also known for brilliant maneuvers and sarcastic wit on the floor of congress.
The negative view in California history texts of the Radical Republicans went along with admiration for the chivalrous Robert E. Lee, who once had an enslaved black woman whipped for insolence.
What had actually made Thaddeus Stevens a villain in American history texts--I discovered many years later-- was his absolute insistence that black men be given citizenship and the right to vote, to sit on juries and to own property after the Civil War. Stevens--who lived with a woman of mixed race and left her a pension when he died-- had no doubt that all men are created equal. At the time (and for the next hundred years), many white men considered that view radical, absurd, even evil.
A few years ago there was a popular movie about a short section of Lincoln's life, and in it, Thaddeus Stevens, played by Tommy Lee Jones, was accurately portrayed as a tough and witty progressive who knew when to compromise. The times they are a'changing.
Repeating the Narrative
Trump fabricates to control the narrative. George Lakoff has written about that. If we respond to Trump's stream of claims and conspiracy theories, he controls the news cycle. To respond thoughtfully, we must repeat and re-enforce his narrative. We argue with an idiot.
That cuts both ways. Right now Trump and his goblins are complaining about impeachment, which strengthens the Democratic narrative through repetition, making impeachment seem more normal day by day.
That cuts both ways. Right now Trump and his goblins are complaining about impeachment, which strengthens the Democratic narrative through repetition, making impeachment seem more normal day by day.
Thursday, October 3, 2019
Finlandia
Watching Colbert I became aware that tRump had missed his chance yesterday to ask the President of Finland to find some dirt on Joe Biden. That was a massive mistake. The President had already asked Ukraine, Italy and Australia to look for dirt, and this morning he asked China, which may or may not owe him a favor. What is Finland, a nothing? A Lindsay Graham? Be fair, Mr. President.
Monday, September 30, 2019
Hunter Biden
From an enormous distance, it appears that Hunter Biden took a job in Ukraine (the ancestral home of my father-in-law's family) for which he was paid about $600,000 a year. His qualification for the job was that he had a politically important father. That's ordinary sleazy capitalism and how it works.
I believe it would be a mistake to nominate Joe Biden. In the past he got elbowed aside by Gore, Kerry and Hillary, all losers, because he was such a lightweight. Since then he has lost forty pounds. He's now a featherweight. I doubt if the Democrats want to lose badly enough to nominate him. But Joe Biden should not be blamed for what his son did, and what Hunter did was ordinary and legal.
Saturday, September 28, 2019
The Gates of Hell
My old friends and I survived Richard Nixon and relished his sweaty downfall. What fun that shaming fall was!
This time around tRump--the cager of children--has been doing his best, out of spite, to hasten the sixth extinction (the fifth extinction took the dinosaurs). But, I say, when times are hard, enjoy the pleasure you find. Watching a malignant, brainless planet killer flail and whine is the next show scheduled. We will now get a year of watching tRump get dragged screaming through the gates of Hell. Savor it.
This time around tRump--the cager of children--has been doing his best, out of spite, to hasten the sixth extinction (the fifth extinction took the dinosaurs). But, I say, when times are hard, enjoy the pleasure you find. Watching a malignant, brainless planet killer flail and whine is the next show scheduled. We will now get a year of watching tRump get dragged screaming through the gates of Hell. Savor it.
Friday, September 27, 2019
Spanking Greta Thunberg
David Futrelle has compiled on the Internet a list of men advising somebody to spank activist Greta Thunberg, a small 16-year-old girl famous for her opposition to a mass dying-off of humanity. One of the pro-spankers is Breibart's John Nolte.
Old men spanking teenage girls is apparently a sex fantasy for those who conflate sex with violence and pain. I don't get it, but it feels appropriate that the fantasy comes from the radical right.
Thursday, September 26, 2019
Eating the Barr
"Sometimes you eat the Barr, " Sam Elliott drawled in THE BIG LEBOWSKY, "and sometimes the Barr eats you." He was quoting from America's book of frontier wisdom. Before the Europeans arrived in the New World with firearms and horses, bears and humans were evenly competing to be the dominant species. Imagine a man on foot with a bow and arrow facing a grizzly.
Arctic horribilis sometimes stood about 8 feet tall and weighed more than 1,000 pounds.
Sam Elliott is famous for many reasons, including his acting, his long marriage to Katherine Ross, his mustache and his very deep voice.
I'm really talking about Bill Barr, of course, an officer horribilis of the court system and the President's complicit enforcer, famous for having lied on an industrial scale to cover up for several Republican eras.
Many people are saying that Barr should be disbarred and then eaten by geese.
Arctic horribilis sometimes stood about 8 feet tall and weighed more than 1,000 pounds.
Sam Elliott is famous for many reasons, including his acting, his long marriage to Katherine Ross, his mustache and his very deep voice.
I'm really talking about Bill Barr, of course, an officer horribilis of the court system and the President's complicit enforcer, famous for having lied on an industrial scale to cover up for several Republican eras.
Many people are saying that Barr should be disbarred and then eaten by geese.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)