Should we give J. D. Vance another chance? He's asked for one. Is he eligible?
Martha Stewart rebounded from a prison sentence. Michael Vick returned to professional football after strangling a dog. Donald Trump was elected president after a failed attempt to learn the flute. (The failure came when he was very young, when his lips were less prehensile.)
In 1932 F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote, "There are no second acts in American lives." But that was 94 years ago, when American lives were shorter.